Black Friday in your Shopify store: setting struck-through prices correctly and following the 30-day rule
Between Black Friday and Christmas, many shops show struck-through prices and "-30%" badges. In Shopify, a struck-through price is set in no time. For it to hold up legally in Germany, the advertised reduction must be calculated from the lowest price of the last 30 days, not from the "normal" price or the most recent price charged.
Struck-through price vs. discount code in Shopify
According to its help centre, Shopify distinguishes two ways:
- Sale price with a "compare-at price": in the product, you enter the old price as the compare-at price and the new one as the price. The compare-at price must be higher than the price. Both values can appear on product and collection pages; at checkout only the sale price is shown. Whether and how the struck-through price appears in the shop, for example as a badge with a percentage, is controlled by your theme.
- Discounts (codes or automatic discounts): the saving is always shown struck through at checkout. On product and collection pages, Shopify doesn't show it as a struck-through price without a third-party app or customisation. How to set up codes properly is covered in our article on Shopify discount codes.
What § 11 PAngV requires
Under § 11 (1) PAngV, anyone who announces a price reduction for a product to consumers must state the lowest total price they applied to consumers within the last 30 days before the price reduction was applied. A struck-through price, a "-20%" banner or a "Black Friday price" are all such announcements.
- Gradual reduction (para. 2): if you keep lowering the price in steps without interruption, you may state the lowest price before the first step began for the duration of the promotion.
- Unit price (para. 3): the rule applies accordingly to retailers who are only required to state the unit price.
- Exceptions (para. 4): individual price reductions, and perishable goods or goods with a short shelf life that are reduced because they are about to spoil or expire, if this is made clear.
The discount must be calculated from the 30-day lowest price
On 26 September 2024, the Court of Justice of the European Union ruled on the underlying EU rule (case C-330/23, Aldi Süd): a reduction advertised as a percentage or with a promotional claim such as "price highlight" must be determined on the basis of the lowest price of the last 30 days. Merely mentioning this price in the small print is not enough. A price advertised as reduced must not be equal to or higher than that previous price.
Shopify store in 24 hours. Want the shop itself up and running before your next promotion? We set it up in 24 hours. €249 total price, ready no later than 24 hours after we receive all access and details. See the package →
Worked example
A hoodie has cost €59 for weeks, but was on offer for €49 for one week in mid-October. On Black Friday you sell it for €44.
If the €49 week falls within the 30 days before Black Friday, €49 is the reference price. The saving is then about 10%, not 25% compared with €59. A "-25%" badge or a compare-at price of €59 as the only reference would be misleading.
How to prepare the promotion in Shopify
- Record the prices of the last 30 days: for every promotional product and variant, note the lowest price that applied in the 30 days before the promotion starts, including short promotions and earlier sale prices.
- No price increase shortly beforehand: raising the price before the promotion doesn't move the reference point up, because the lower price remains decisive for 30 days.
- Set the compare-at price to the lowest price: if you enter the 30-day lowest price in the "Compare-at price" field, theme badges calculate the percentage from the correct base.
- Keep variants consistent: according to Shopify, a collection page won't show a product as reduced if its variants have conflicting compare-at prices (empty, 0.00 or different values). 0.00 is not the same as an empty field.
- Check banners and newsletters: "up to -40%" in banners, emails and social posts is also an announcement. The figure must match the actual reference prices.
- Reset after the promotion: clear or adjust compare-at prices again so no permanent struck-through price is left behind.
- Update the unit price too: for goods with a unit price, the promotional price needs the matching unit price (see unit prices in your Shopify store).
Checklist
- ☐ Lowest price of the last 30 days noted for each product and variant
- ☐ Percentages and struck-through prices calculated from the 30-day lowest price
- ☐ No price increase shortly before the promotion starts
- ☐ Compare-at prices consistent across all variants, no 0.00 values
- ☐ Banners, newsletters and social posts use the same figures
- ☐ Time zone and start/end of discount codes checked
- ☐ Delivery time information up to date for the Christmas season (shipping costs and delivery time)
- ☐ Test order with the promotional price carried out
- ☐ Date noted for resetting the compare-at prices
§ 11 PAngV (gesetze-im-internet.de) · CJEU, judgment of 26 September 2024, C-330/23 (EUR-Lex) · Shopify Help: setting sale prices
If you want an outside second opinion before the Christmas season, the Ladenfertig Launch-Check reviews your shop independently for a €149 final price (§ 19 UStG, no VAT shown), with an automated written report and a prioritised fix list; ask about availability via the enquiry form. Need more depth or a build? The Launch-Check stays the review; Store, Pro and Premium cover setup. An Extended Audit is only available on request via the enquiry page.
Free tool: the free strikethrough price check lists every variant in your Shopify store whose compare-at price is higher than the price, with the discount in percent. The 30-day check stays your job, because the tool cannot see price history.
No time before Black Friday? Our €99 BF price check checks up to 50 discounted products against the 30-day low and delivers the correction list within 2 business days.
Note: the explanations of § 11 PAngV and the CJEU ruling reflect the wording of the law and the decision and do not replace legal advice in an individual case. This article is not legal or tax advice. Labels and workflows in the Shopify admin may change; double-check them in your own account.