Setting up Shopify returns and refunds correctly: withdrawal, return costs, refund, correction document
After Black Friday and Christmas at the latest, the returns arrive. Shopify can now handle returns, return labels, refunds and self-service requests pretty well. What Shopify doesn't know is what German withdrawal law requires. Here you'll read which deadlines and costs the law sets, how to configure Shopify's return and cancellation rules to match, what the withdrawal function in force since June 2026 means and how refunds and correction documents fit together.
Shopify store in 24 hours. No shop yet? We set up Shopify and integrate your withdrawal and returns texts to your specifications. €249 total price, ready no later than 24 hours after we receive all access and details. See the package →
Up front: no legal advice
This guide reflects the statutory wording (BGB, EGBGB, UStG, UStDV) and Shopify Help (all checked on 5 November 2026) and shows where to set what in Shopify. It does not replace legal advice. Whether a right of withdrawal applies to your range, how your withdrawal notice must read and whether your setup meets the withdrawal function requirement is something to clarify with a lawyer or a specialised legal-text provider. For tax questions about corrections, your tax adviser is the right contact.
Withdrawal, voluntary returns, warranty: three different things
In Shopify, almost everything is called a "return". Legally, you should keep three cases apart:
- Withdrawal: for distance contracts, consumers have a right of withdrawal under § 355 BGB (§ 312g(1) BGB). They don't have to give a reason, and the declaration only has to make the decision to withdraw clear (§ 355(1) BGB). This is the case this guide is mainly about.
- Voluntary return: you can additionally promise a longer return right (for example 30 days). That doesn't replace the right of withdrawal, and the statutory minimum standards still apply.
- Warranty: if the goods are defective, statutory warranty law applies, not withdrawal. You must point out that it exists and its minimum duration of two years in your pre-contract information (Art. 246a § 1(1) no. 11 EGBGB).
For your Shopify settings, this means: your return rules must cover the right of withdrawal at a minimum. You may be more generous, but not stricter. Unless otherwise provided, the withdrawal rules may not be deviated from to the detriment of consumers (§ 361(2) BGB).
Deadlines: when the 14 days start and when they end
- The withdrawal period is 14 days (§ 355(2) BGB). To meet the deadline, it is enough to send the withdrawal in time (§ 355(1) sentence 5 BGB).
- Start for goods (§ 356(2) no. 1 BGB): as soon as the customer (or a named third party who is not the carrier) has received the goods. For several items in one order delivered separately, or for partial shipments, the last item or partial shipment counts; for regular deliveries (subscriptions), the first.
- No start without a notice: the period doesn't begin before you have informed the customer about the right of withdrawal under Art. 246a § 1(2) sentence 1 no. 1 EGBGB (§ 356(3) BGB). The right of withdrawal then expires at the latest twelve months and 14 days after the period would actually have started (§ 356(4) BGB). If the start of the period is disputed, the burden of proof is on you (§ 361(3) BGB).
In Shopify, you set the return window under Settings > Policies > Return and cancellation rules. For customers in the EU, Shopify Help explicitly recommends: a return window of at least 14 days, Starts from set to delivery of the last item in the order and the option to extend for weekends or holidays. Important from Shopify Help: if the delivery date isn't known, Shopify calculates from the fulfilment date plus a buffer. So without tracking, Shopify's window can end earlier than the statutory period. Also: if return rules were disabled at the time of purchase, customers can, according to Shopify, request a return without any time limit; changes to the rules only apply to future orders.
Exceptions: when there is no right of withdrawal
§ 312g(2) BGB lists contracts for which there is no right of withdrawal unless otherwise agreed. For typical shops, these are the most relevant:
- No. 1: goods that are not prefabricated and whose production depends on an individual selection or specification by the customer, or that are clearly tailored to personal needs (e.g. engraving, made-to-measure),
- No. 2: goods that can spoil quickly or whose expiry date would quickly be exceeded,
- No. 3: sealed goods that are not suitable for return for health protection or hygiene reasons, if the seal was removed after delivery,
- No. 4: goods that, due to their nature, were inseparably mixed with other goods after delivery,
- No. 6: audio or video recordings or software in a sealed package, if the seal was removed,
- No. 7: newspapers, periodicals or magazines, except subscriptions.
If an exception applies or the right of withdrawal can expire early, you must inform the customer (Art. 246a § 1(3) EGBGB). In Shopify, you mark such products or collections as final sale items; customers can then not submit a return or cancellation request for them.
Careful with "final sale"
Shopify Help lists "heavily discounted items", among others, as examples of final sale items. But a discount is not on the exception list in § 312g(2) BGB. For customers in Germany and the EU, only mark products as final sale where a statutory exception actually applies, and check this per product. According to Shopify Help, digital goods and personalised products are also not automatically excluded from self-service cancellations; you review those requests manually.
The withdrawal function since 19 June 2026 (§ 356a BGB)
For distance contracts concluded via an online interface, you must provide a withdrawal function under § 356a BGB. According to the German federal government, the relevant law has entered into force (announcement of 19 June 2026), and Shopify Help also names 19 June 2026. The key points from the statutory text:
- The function is clearly labelled "Vertrag widerrufen" (withdraw from contract) or an equivalent unambiguous wording and is permanently available, prominently placed and easily accessible during the withdrawal period (para. 1).
- Customers can easily enter or confirm their name, details identifying the contract (or part of the contract) and the electronic means of communication for the acknowledgement of receipt (para. 2).
- This is followed by a confirmation function, labelled "Widerruf bestätigen" (confirm withdrawal) or an equivalent unambiguous wording (para. 3).
- You send an acknowledgement of receipt without undue delay on a durable medium, containing at least the content of the declaration and the date and time of receipt (para. 4).
Your withdrawal notice may also need to inform customers about the existence and placement of the withdrawal function (Art. 246a § 1(2) sentence 1 no. 1 EGBGB). The statutory model (Annex 1 to the EGBGB) contains its own text block for this, with the web address of the function. More on the requirements in the guide Electronic withdrawal function since 19 June 2026.
What Shopify offers for this
According to Shopify Help, you can use Shopify's return and cancellation rules together with self-service returns and cancellations in customer accounts to meet the electronic withdrawal function requirement. For the EU, Shopify recommends:
- Under Settings > Customer accounts, enable self-service returns and cancellations (depending on the shop, in the Order actions section or directly in the customer account settings; for some markets only on the Advanced or Plus plan).
- Enable cancellation rules and set the cancellation window to until the item is fulfilled.
- Return window of at least 14 days from delivery of the last item, extended over weekends and holidays.
- Add a visible link to customer accounts or the order page, for example via Content > Menus in the footer and as a link in the Right of withdrawal section under Settings > Policies.
Shopify itself notes that using these tools does not automatically make your shop compliant. So check specifically against § 356a BGB:
- Labelling: according to Shopify Help, the buttons in the customer account are called Cancel items, Return items or Cancel or return (in German: Artikel stornieren, Artikel zurückgeben, Stornieren oder zurückgeben). Whether that counts in your shop as an "equivalent unambiguous wording" to "Vertrag widerrufen" or "Widerruf bestätigen" should be checked legally. In any case, label your menu link unambiguously, for example "Vertrag widerrufen".
- Access: to make a request, customers sign in to the customer account with their email address and a six-digit code. Test whether this works smoothly for guest orders and on mobile.
- Acknowledgement of receipt: after a request, Shopify automatically sends the Return request confirmation email (customisable under Settings > Notifications > Returns). Check that it contains the content of the declaration and the date and time of receipt.
- "Decline" is not a withdrawal filter: in Shopify you can approve or decline return requests. But the withdrawal itself needs no approval and no reason. Declining only comes into question if an exception really applies or the period has expired.
If you use Managed Markets, Shopify Help says it automatically applies suitable cancellation and return terms to EU orders. If you use a returns app, check the same four points in the app.
Model withdrawal form and online form
You must provide information about the model withdrawal form (Annex 2 to the EGBGB) (Art. 246a § 1(2) sentence 1 no. 1 EGBGB). It contains: your name, address and email address; the sentence "Hiermit widerrufe(n) ich/wir (*) den von mir/uns (*) abgeschlossenen Vertrag über den Kauf der folgenden Waren (*)…" (I/we hereby withdraw from the contract concluded by me/us for the purchase of the following goods); "Bestellt am (*)/erhalten am (*)" (ordered on/received on); the consumer's name and address; signature (only on paper); date. Customers don't have to use it; any unambiguous declaration is enough. If you also offer your own online form, you must confirm receipt of the withdrawal without undue delay on a durable medium (§ 356(1) BGB).
Return costs: who pays?
- Customers only bear the direct costs of returning the goods if you informed them of this beforehand under Art. 246a § 1(2) sentence 1 no. 2 EGBGB, and not if you agreed to bear the costs (§ 357(5) BGB). Without this information, you pay.
- For goods that, due to their nature, cannot normally be returned by post (e.g. freight items), in distance selling you must also state the amount of these costs (Art. 246a § 1(2) sentence 1 no. 2 EGBGB); the model provides for an amount or an estimate.
- You bear the risk of the return shipment (§ 355(3) sentence 4 BGB). If the parcel gets lost on the way, that's your risk.
- If you offer to collect the goods, customers don't have to send them back (§ 357(6) BGB).
In Shopify's return rules, under Return shipping you choose: free return shipping, a flat return shipping fee per return or customers buy their own label. The setting must match your withdrawal notice: if it says "We bear the costs of returning the goods", Shopify must not show a fee. The law speaks of the direct costs of returning; whether a flat fee that exceeds your actual postage fits that is something to clarify legally before you set it.
A detail for shops in Germany: according to Shopify Help, creating return labels in Shopify only works if you have a location in the same country as the delivery address and that country is the USA or Canada. Here, you upload a label from your carrier (PDF, PNG, JPEG or URL, optionally with a tracking number) or choose No shipping required.
Restocking fee and compensation for loss of value
Shopify allows a percentage restocking fee. For withdrawals, however: beyond the statutory provisions, there are no further claims against consumers as a result of the withdrawal (§ 361(1) BGB), and a restocking fee doesn't appear in those provisions. What the law does recognise is compensation for loss of value caused by handling the goods in a way not necessary to examine them, and only if you properly informed the customer about the right of withdrawal (§ 357a(1) BGB). That is a case-by-case decision, not a flat fee. So for withdrawals, it's best to leave the field empty; have a fee for purely voluntary returns outside the withdrawal right checked first.
Refund: deadline, amount, payment method
- Deadline: payments received must be returned within 14 days at the latest (§ 357(1) BGB). For you, the period starts with receipt of the withdrawal declaration (§ 355(3) sentence 2 BGB), not only when the goods arrive.
- Withholding: for a purchase, you can withhold the refund until you have the goods back or the customer proves they sent them (§ 357(4) BGB), unless you offered collection.
- Outbound shipping costs: you also refund payments for delivery, except the extra costs if someone chose a more expensive shipping method than your cheapest standard delivery (§ 357(2) BGB). For express, you refund the standard delivery amount.
- Payment method: you refund using the same means of payment, unless something else was expressly agreed and the customer incurs no costs (§ 357(3) BGB). So store credit instead of money is only possible for withdrawals with an express agreement.
How it works in Shopify (according to Shopify Help): for a return, create the return first with a return reason (Orders > order > Return) and refund afterwards. After a refund, you can no longer create a return, and without a return the return reason is missing from reports. When refunding, you choose the quantity, optionally Refund shipping with an amount, the refund method (original payment method, store credit or both) and whether the customer notification is sent.
- According to Shopify, a refund cannot be cancelled or undone. Check the amount and method before you click.
- Shopify does not automatically deduct return fees from the refund. You have to deduct them manually, which is tricky anyway for withdrawals, as described above.
- You can't refund shipping if an order-level free shipping discount was applied (there's nothing to refund then).
- With a gift card plus another payment method, Shopify applies partial refunds to the gift card first. You can adjust the split manually. Make sure it fits the "same means of payment" rule.
- With Shopify Payments, credit card fees are not refunded to you on a refund. Factor that into your returns costs, not into the refund amount.
Correction document: the refund in your bookkeeping
If you refund in full or in part, the consideration changes. If you are subject to standard taxation, you must correct the tax owed (§ 17(1) UStG). In practice, this produces a correction document with negative amounts that refers unambiguously to the original invoice (number and date). You don't edit the original invoice afterwards. If details in the invoice itself were wrong or mandatory details were missing, that's a different case: a correction via a document that refers specifically and unambiguously to the invoice (§ 31(5) UStDV).
- Label: call the document "Rechnungskorrektur" (invoice correction) or "Stornorechnung zu Rechnung …" (cancellation invoice for invoice …). In German VAT law, "Gutschrift" means an invoice issued by the customer; details in the guide Shopify invoices for Germany.
- Same tax rates: for mixed baskets at 19% and 7%, you correct per tax rate, just as the original invoice was broken down. Refunded shipping belongs in the correction too.
- Small businesses (§ 19 UStG) don't show tax, so there's nothing to correct for VAT purposes. A document for the refund still makes sense for bookkeeping, without a tax line.
- Tool: by default, Shopify Order Printer has no template for correction documents. For those, you need an invoicing app or your accounting software (overview in the invoices guide); check an app's features in its App Store listing. Agree with your tax adviser which label and process suit you.
Return policy and withdrawal notice in Shopify
Under Settings > Policies you'll find the return and refund policy and a Right of withdrawal section. According to Shopify Help, you can use an automated policy fed by your return rules, or maintain the text yourself; the policy appears automatically in the footer of the checkout pages. Shopify points out that you are responsible for your published policy yourself.
For German shops: the withdrawal notice follows Art. 246a § 1(2) EGBGB; you can meet the obligation with the statutory model in Annex 1 if you send it correctly filled in in text form. The model contains the text blocks on the start of the period ("die Waren in Besitz genommen haben", i.e. taken possession of the goods), return costs, repayment, withholding and compensation for loss of value. Your returns page, the Shopify rules and the notice must say the same thing, especially on return costs and the start of the period. How to integrate legal texts in Shopify is covered in the guide Integrating Shopify legal texts.
Checking with a test return
Ideally, run through a return once before the Christmas season (test order in detail: Shopify test order before launch):
- Place and fulfil a test order with two products, shipping and a discount code.
- As the customer, open the withdrawal or return function via the footer link, on a phone and as a guest with the email code.
- Check the labelling, requested details and confirmation email against § 356a BGB (content, date, time).
- In the admin, create the return, upload a label, then partially refund, including standard shipping.
- Check that no restocking or return fee was deducted that your notice doesn't provide for, and that the refund goes to the original means of payment.
- Generate a correction document and check that it refers unambiguously to the original invoice.
Common mistakes we look for in the Launch-Check
- Return window from fulfilment instead of delivery of the last item, or shorter than 14 days.
- Discounted goods as "final sale" without a statutory exception.
- Withdrawal function hidden, only behind the login icon, without a clearly labelled link in the footer or withdrawal notice.
- Contradictory return costs: the notice says "we bear the costs", Shopify shows a fee, or vice versa.
- Restocking fee enabled for withdrawals.
- Refund only as store credit or only after weeks instead of within 14 days of receiving the withdrawal.
- Outbound shipping costs not refunded.
- Refund created without a return, so no return reason is recorded, and no correction document for the original invoice.
- English notifications for return requests ("Return request") because the templates under Settings > Notifications > Returns were never adjusted for German customers.
Checklist
- ☐ Return rules active: at least 14 days, from delivery of the last item, extended over weekends/holidays
- ☐ Cancellation rules active: "until the item is fulfilled"
- ☐ Self-service returns and cancellations active, customer accounts reachable, clearly labelled link in footer and withdrawal notice
- ☐ Process checked against § 356a BGB: labelling, name, order, email, confirmation step, acknowledgement with date and time
- ☐ Final sale items only for genuine exceptions under § 312g(2) BGB, with notice under Art. 246a § 1(3) EGBGB
- ☐ Return costs: Shopify setting = withdrawal notice
- ☐ No restocking fee for withdrawals
- ☐ Refund within 14 days, including standard shipping, to the original means of payment
- ☐ Create the return first, then refund; correction document referring to the original invoice
- ☐ Notifications for returns and refunds in German
- ☐ Test return run through on a phone
Have the returns path and purchase path checked from the outside
The Ladenfertig Launch-Check reviews your shop from the outside, without a login and without making changes: whether the returns page, link to the withdrawal function, legal texts, shipping and price information, checkout and order confirmation are visibly present and fit together. Within two working days you get a prioritised fix list as an automated written report. €149 final price (no VAT is shown under § 19 UStG). No legal or tax advice and no legal review of your texts' content. Need more depth or a build? Store, Pro and Premium cover setup; an Extended Audit is only available on request.
Request a Launch-Check →§ 312g BGB · § 355 BGB · § 356 BGB · § 356a BGB · § 357 BGB · § 357a BGB · § 361 BGB · Art. 246a § 1 EGBGB · Annex 1 EGBGB (model withdrawal notice) · Annex 2 EGBGB (model withdrawal form) · § 17 UStG · § 31 UStDV · German federal government: more consumer protection for online contracts (19 June 2026, German) · Shopify Help: returns and exchanges · Shopify Help: creating returns and exchanges · Shopify Help: return and cancellation rules · Shopify Help: self-serve returns · Shopify Help: setting up self-serve returns · Shopify Help: refunding orders · Shopify Help: EU right of withdrawal
Note: this article reflects the statutory wording and Shopify Help and is not legal or tax advice. Ladenfertig is not a law firm. Whether a right of withdrawal applies to your range, how your withdrawal notice must read, whether your setup meets the withdrawal function under § 356a BGB and how you book corrections is something to clarify bindingly with a lawyer, a specialised legal-text provider or your tax adviser. Labels and workflows in the Shopify admin can change and partly depend on your plan and early access; check them in your own account too.